Name: Little Italy's Pizza
Price range: $$

Little Italy's Pizza Information

If you're in the mood for a hearty, satisfying meal that feels like home, Little Italy's Pizza in Mt. Carmel, IL is a spot you won’t want to miss. Nestled at 502 N Walnut St, this cozy gem serves up some of the best pizza in the area, with a menu that brings together classic Italian flavors and a welcoming, down-to-earth atmosphere.

Walking into the restaurant, you're immediately struck by the warm, inviting vibe. The space has that perfect mix of casual comfort and a hint of old-school charm, making it ideal for everything from a quick bite to a more relaxed evening with family and friends. The staff is incredibly friendly, always ready to offer a recommendation or chat about their specials, which adds to the overall sense of community you feel as soon as you walk through the door.

The menu is a delightful mix of Italian favorites, but it's the pizza that really steals the show. The crust strikes that perfect balance between crispy and soft, making each bite an absolute treat. Whether you're a fan of a simple Margherita or looking for something a bit more adventurous, like their loaded Supreme pizza, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The toppings are fresh, and the generous amount of cheese pulls you in with each slice, leaving you wanting more.

For those looking for variety, Little Italy's Pizza offers a range of pastas, subs, and salads that keep everyone happy. The lasagna is a crowd favorite-rich, savory, and comforting. If you’re in the mood for something light, the house salad, with its tangy vinaigrette, pairs perfectly with any dish. And don’t forget to try their garlic bread, which comes out warm and perfectly toasted, a great way to start any meal.

Service is consistently friendly and prompt. Even during the busier times, the waitstaff ensures you're taken care of and keeps the atmosphere laid-back. You might find yourself returning just as much for the service and warmth as for the food itself.

Little Italy's Pizza is not just a restaurant; it’s a beloved part of the Mt. Carmel community, where locals and visitors alike come together to enjoy a great meal. With its inviting environment and top-notch pizza, it’s no surprise this spot consistently receives rave reviews. Whether you're in the mood for a slice of pizza after a busy day or a relaxed dinner with loved ones, you can count on Little Italy's Pizza to deliver a memorable experience every time.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

My wife and I ordered pizza and cheese bread from there tonight! When I first walked in I loved the inside! It’s cute and small. Would be nice for a little family dinner or lunch. The service was good. The girls at the counter was sweet and one of the guys from the back was super nice! Bragging about how good the pizza is! Well he did not disappoint! The pizza looked absolutely amazing! So did the cheese bread. Their cheese bread was delicious. The crust was not too thick or too thin. We ordered a hand tossed 16” pizza! Look at how huge that pizza is!!! Wowzers! We both was very impressed with their pizza. It was so delicious. Their cheese sauce and marinara sauce was good for dipping sauces as well. The one thing we was hoping for. We ordered extra cheese and it just didn’t seem like we received extra cheese. But it’s not their fault! We are just cheese fanatics! Such a good quality pizza from a small family business! Definitely recommend and we will be back!

Place has been around for years. Pizza has a lot of toppings on it and the breadsticks are soft. Food comes out hot and delicious.

I was just driving buy today with my family and we ordered pizza there today and the food was delicious. Good job to the cooks.

This pizza parlor is the bomb! We’ve been getting some foods for years now. They do it all right! Whether sandwiches or salads or pizza or pasta, it’s all delicious! The chef chicken salad is a wonderful way to end a hot summer day with. The sub sandwich is top notch! We love the Italian version. Pasta and roast beef are excellent choices for a meal. Stop by for a delicious meal. Little Italy ‘s , “we love to feed you!”

Ordered a few pizzas delivered to Gibson power plant. Chicago style is excellent, although twice now we haven't received exactly what we ordered so maybe their communication & accuracy could be improved but it's still great pizza!

Wow, a little hidden gem. Great service and excellent food. I can't say enough about it. My son ate here before. Since then he has been asking to go with me there. So glad he did. Super easy, five stars. I hope people read this review and check this place out!!!

Breadsticks have stayed the same since I was a kid. Still good

This is the best pizza in town in my opinion. Always hot and fresh, great ingredients, sauce, and crust, they never mess up an order, and we really like the option they have now with the family feast deals where you can get extra bread sticks instead of drinks. That definitely goes further with our family of five! And never a long wait for food. I think the longest we have had to wait is 30 minutes.

Little Italy's Pizza